Mini Air Fryer Pumpkin Pie Recipe

Ninja Foodi Pumpkin Pie

I cannot go without all of the easy pumpkin dessert recipes I make every single year. It is my all time favorite flavor and I am guilty of using it all year long, if I can find it. 😉 These are our latest creations. Of course we used to do the same thing in our oven but this is much quicker.

Love that you can make them in a mini version too. If you have your own pie filling recipe you can by all means use that. We have one explained below though.

Air Fryer Mini Pumpkin Pies

You can use whatever brand you have at home but I love this square basket because it holds a lot. I just used the classic Libby’s pumpkin pie recipe on the back of the can and went from there.

In the baking aisle I found these fun mini Keebler pie crusts too, I thought those would be perfect. I’m all about easy so…if you insist on homemade then go for it. I have used this can for not just pies, Libbys pumpkin muffins are great too so grab a few and go crazy.

This is how we made them the other day together, they were a yummy treat after dinnertime with ready made crusts. If you wanted a lower carb style like our Impossible Pumpkin Pie without the outsides you could do these in ramekins.

Air Fryer Pie

First let’s tackle a few questions you might have before you go any further starting with How to Tell if a Pumpkin Pie is Done? There are a few factors and if done right it won’t get dried out and be perfect for every bite.

There are many brands that sell canned pumpkin but this is the most well known. You can also make fresh Instant Pot pumpkin puree if you wish.

Items you’re going to need, or what we used in this case. Timing is appropriate for these small graham cracker crust shells you see here.

Mini Pumpkin Pie Ingredients

1. Can of pumpkin puree
2. Mini pie crusts
3. Evaporated milk
4. Sugar
5. Salt
6. Cinnamon
7. Ginger
8. Cloves
9. Eggs

You can surely add some pumpkin pie spice if you’d like too. Of course you’ll need your air fryer oven. Any brand as we said above. Phillips, Nuwave oven, Foodi. etc. If you have a toaster oven / air fryer combo you could likely fit a regular size pan, it would just take longer to cook.

Pumpkin Pies in Air Fryer

I chose to preheat for 5 minutes at 320 degrees to begin with. If you do too you’ll have to fill with pie filling after setting them into the basket because it will already be hot. (don’t burn yourself lowering them inside already filled)

1. Just use a 1/4 measuring cup to scoop and fill each one so they are as full as you see here. Be careful when closing so they don’t spill over.
   • You can fit 4 at a time if you have a air fryer basket similar to this one. Use several packages to make a bunch for your crew, or pour the remainder into an air fryer pot like you see here below.
2. Preheat air fryer to 320 degrees F for 5 minutes.
3. Whisk together all ingredients until smooth.
4. When preheated set 4 tins inside air fryer.
5. Use a 1/4 c. measuring cup to scoop filling into graham cracker crusts until there is a bit of space at the top.
6. Close drawer and cook at 320 for 8 minutes until outer edges have firmed up.
   • (if you add more filling you might need to add 1-2 more minutes until set)

Remove carefully with tongs (or remove basket and leave out of machine with pies inside to cool). Allow to rest and continue to firm up and cool on cooling rack. Add another batch and continue until all are done. They should look similar to these to know they are set. The middle will look a bit more wet but that is okay as long as it isn’t liquid.

Air Fryer Crustless Pumpkin Pie

I tried this to see how this “crust free pie” would turn out and just experimented. 350 degrees for about 45 minutes did the trick with the last few minutes uncovered. I took it out once the center was solidified. My husband preferred this method really and that was devoured that night as well.

How to Bake Pie in Air Fryer

Looking for other air fryer desserts? We have a bunch of them to choose from.

• Try this chocolate lava air fryer cake sometime as well.
• We love air fryer cinnamon rolls for after dinner or a breakfast recipe.
• If you’ve never made air fryer cookies or air fryer hand pies you must!

Before you go I want you to sign up for my free newsletter!! You will get all my new recipes emailed to you a few times a week that will help with meal planning for the week.