How to Cook a Moist Turkey

How to cook a moist turkey 4 different ways! If you want smoked turkey, baked, roasted, on a sheet pan in an Instant Pot, even a turkey crown. We will share tips for perfection. 

Wondering how to cook a moist turkey, and maybe try a new method this year?? We have FOUR different ways and how to keep the meat moist no matter which one you choose. (affiliate links present)

How to Cook a Juicy Turkey

• #1 – First of all if you want the most flavorful seasoning on the outside, follow our smoked turkey dry rub for best results.

Even if you aren’t smoking your turkey it is the best!! Baked, roasted, pressure cooked, or any way you make it the seasonings on the outside is where it’s at!!

• #2 – Remember to completely thaw your turkey before cooking! That takes time, the chart below will help with this.
• #3 – Cook with the turkey breast side down on a Turkey DunRite holder! (seen below)
  • Makes the dark and white meat EXTREMELY moist.
• #4 – Baste the turkey inside your roasting pan at least once every few hours.
• #5 – The next tip is to NOT over bake your bird! You’ll need a meat thermometer for this.

If you’re following a recipe that is great, however the size of your turkey will determine the amount of cook time in the oven. To make the perfect turkey you can print this how long to thaw and cook a turkey

How long do you cook a 10 pound turkey and at what temperature?

This print out will help with that! Now what do you do once it’s done?

• #6 – When you remove the turkey, make sure it is cooked through!
  • A whole turkey is safe when cooked to a minimum internal temperature of 165 °F measured with a food thermometer placed in the innermost part of the thigh.
  • Always take this temperature once it has been removed from the heat source for an accurate read.
  • Keep in mind that during the resting period the turkey will keep cooking, and the internal temperature will rise by 5 to 10 degrees. Pull it out as soon as the temperature hits 165 degrees.

There’s nothing worse than thinking your turkey is done, allowing it to rest, and then once you slice it realizing it’s not safe to eat. Bad. News.

• #7 – Get your skin crispy

How do you get turkey skin crispy?

• Added fat will help the skin crisp while it cooks so rub room temperature or melted butter poured all over the skin will work. 
• Then season it liberally if you haven’t already.
  • If you have you could add a bit more salt and pepper now.
• Cook at 425 degrees for 20 – 30 minutes. Rotate the pan and baste it again, then decrease the heat to 350 degrees for the remainder of the time until the top of the turkey is as crispy as you’d like.

OR you can add separate pieces in your air fryer like we did with our turkey thighs recipe.

• #8 – Allow your Thanksgiving turkey to rest.
  • This is probably once of the most important ways of how to cook a moist turkey.
  • Slicing a turkey immediately will release the juices, and not in a good way. You want all that goodness to stay inside the bird and in each piece you eat. 

How long does turkey need to rest?

A minimum of 20 minutes is suggested, we usually do 30. Of course the amount of resting time depends on the size of the bird, but at least 20 minutes is needed to cook a juicy turkey

Can I prep a turkey a day before?

You can mix together your seasonings like you see here and rub it on, then refrigerate it. This will make your skin more flavorful than putting it on just before you cook it. Keep in mind it may be too salty for you as it would essentially be a dry brine. Some do it this way and rinse it off before baking.

Always stuff the turkey just before putting it in the oven. You can, however make the stuffing the night before, then refrigerate it until you’re ready to roast it.

If you’re looking for a way to save space in your oven this year, and/or cook it quickly, try our pressure cooker turkey!

Want the most amazing breast meat ever with a serious dry rub you’ll be talking about for Thanksgivings to come?? THIS IS IT!!

Seriously, this will be the best smoked turkey recipe you’ll ever try! These are the ingredients you’ll need to make this winner of a dinner. 😉

1. First you’ll need to make our secret smoked turkey rub recipe so the outside skin is killer!
2. Then grab a turkey of your choice, ours was 11 pounds
3. Old Bay seasoning is my favorite ingredient
4. Olive oil spray
5. Sea salt
6. Garlic powder
7. Cayenne
8. Paprika
9. Thyme

It’s one of our easy smoker recipes and is MY favorite way to cook a bird.

So first choose which method you want to choose, then make sure you follow these tips so it is tender and juicy.

How do I make sure my turkey is moist?

1. Choose a fresh turkey vs. a frozen one.
   1. almost every grocery store has this option but you may need to ask the butcher about it
   2. many times you order it ahead of time and pick it up when they arrive
   3. keep refrigerated until it’s time to prepare it
2. Using this Turkey DunRite holder is an amazing way to cook a moist turkey
   1. works in the oven
   2. you can throw it on a grill and smoke it like we did above
   3. creates very moist turkey breasts and a prettier bird overall once it is done
3. Brine a turkey in a salt and water solution so it’s moister and adds seasoning overall to the bird.
   1. recipe using this method is below in the recipe card.

Here are a few more tips when cooking a Thanksgiving turkey.

Best way to cook turkey in the oven

• Cut the turkey into smaller pieces like you see here with our sheet pan turkey.
  • need to cook a turkey fast and make sure it’s fall off the bone fabulous? This is a great way to do it.
  • takes just about an hour to cook the entire thing
  • or you could cook two smaller birds vs a larger 15 pound size
• Don’t overcook it!!
  • pay close attention to it no matter which way you decide to cook it
  • set a timer for the minimum amount of time for that size and check every 15 minutes or so
  • accurate temperatures are taken when it is removed from the heat source and thermometer is placed in the center of the thigh
• Do not carve it right away!
  • this takes patience and it is worth the wait
  • give it at least 20 minutes to sit and rest so the juices flow into the center of the bird
  • this way you’ll get moister turkey slices and everyone will enjoy it more

How to Make a Turkey Moist and Not Dry

This method is where you are going to use a turkey brine at the beginning and let it soak overnight in your fridge. First you need to make space for it there, and have a large stockpot accessible so it can be submerged into the liquid. From there you will need:

Ingredients

1. Turkey
2. Kosher salt
3. Water
4. Apple
5. Celery

If there are other items you like to stuff into the cavity, use those as well. Full printable recipe for this type of cooking a turkey is below in the recipe card.

The last method I haven’t tried yet would be to cook a crockpot turkey. You would have to choose a rather small bird to do this but I imagine it would turn out incredibly moist. I am definitely a fan of slow cooker recipes so I’m going to try it this way soon and report back. 

• The only thing I would be hesitant about would be the skin. Of course you could pop it under the broiler once it’s done. I would be curious to see just how brown you could get it to be though after sitting in a pot all day. To be determined my friends!

How to get crispy turkey skin

• I always dry the bird with paper towels and then season. After that roasting, smoking, baking etc.. would occur and that works great. If your skin is moist it won’t crisp as well, that’s the key.
• You can rub with a baking soda mixture or raise to a higher temp like our Baked Turkey Wings in Oven. Once again, this draws all the moisture out so it can brown nicely and get as crispy as possible.
• Air drying the bird for 24 hours accomplishes the same thing.
• Last but not least you can air dry and then baste during roasting to get that golden glow.

How do you get a golden brown turkey skin?

Rub a softened stick of butter ALL over the bird. Coating the skin with butter will help to keep the meat moist, add flavor, and ensure the skin turns a perfect golden brown color.

Sides to serve it with

• This is the best Pepperidge Farm Sausage Stuffing Recipe
• Add a loaf of pressure cooker cornbread to your table.

How long is leftover turkey good for in the fridge?

Most leftover turkey can be kept in the fridge safely in an air tight container or freezer bag for 3 -4 days. If you aren’t going to eat all of it in that time frame you should freeze it. Do this within 2 hours after it has been cooked. This is usually the time when you’re doing clean up so maybe refrigerate half, and freeze the rest. 

Remember when storing it to remove all the air out of your storage container. This will prevent freezer burn and keep it fresh longer. Reheat to an internal temperature of 165 degrees F. Then make our leftover turkey recipe. We also make Instant Pot turkey soup with it.

How do you keep sliced turkey moist?

Arrange turkey slices and pieces on baking pan with cut edges of breast slices pressed together. This is going to prevent them from drying out. Cover with plastic wrap. Press it down onto the meat to remove any air pockets. Cover entire pan with lid or aluminum foil. Refrigerate as directed above.

That’s what we do with our air fryer turkey breast.

After a few days your meat may begin to dry out in the fridge, so what do you do then?

What can you make with dry turkey breast?

• Everyone knows to add some gravy to moisten up a roasted turkey or dried out turkey breast, but chicken stock is really the key to this tip. First, cut the breast into small pieces.
• Then dredge them in a pot of warm chicken broth to give it some liquid to soak up. Arrange them on a serving platter and add a little gravy to the top.
• Voila, you’ve revived your dried out turkey! A great hack to make your turkey moist again.
• This is a great tip if it is the big day and you overcooked your bird too….eeeeek!

Have a Happy Thanksgiving any way you prepare your bird!