Instant Pot Chocolate Rice Pudding

Instant Pot chocolate rice pudding is the most amazing Ninja Foodi or pressure cooker dessert you will ever make. It’s quick, smooth, and full of chocolate! I thought of making this after my Instant Pot rice pudding recipe was such a huge hit on social media, you’ve gotta make it this week!

Seriously, you have got to try this Instant Pot chocolate rice pudding, it is amazing!! It’s one our long list of easy Instant Pot recipes where you can find lots of other ideas! If you want a warm dessert cooked in a fraction of the time as your stovetop this is it. (affiliate links present)

Ninja Foodi Chocolate Rice Pudding

Both the traditional version and this one with chocolate came out so creamy and delicious a lot faster than on the stovetop. You can make it dairy free or regular, enjoy it as a snack or dessert after dinner.

Then I could thought I’d make another one with a chocolate twist. It turned out so good I had to share it! Of course anything is better with a little chocolate right?? I basically used the same easy recipe in my pressure cooker and added a few tbsp. of cocoa powder. You can easily use whatever brand of electric pot you might have. I have a few of them but typically use this one and my Ninja Foodi the most.

Chocolate Rice Pudding Recipe

It’s so rich and creamy that you only need a little bowl full for dessert but seriously, you will make this over and over again when you see how easy and delicious it really is. It doesn’t take much prep but you do need to be present right when the timer goes off.

It is a sensitive treat I guess you could say. You don’t want it to cook too long or the texture will be off, and that would be tragic. Using long grain rice allows you to make the basic recipe and then tweak it with even chocolate chips on top if you want to add even more.

Homemade Chocolate Rice Pudding

We were always huge fans of rice pudding but when I got my Instant Pot and made it for myself in less than 15 minutes it became our go to pressure cooker dessert of choice. There are 5 of us and this recipe is just enough for us with NO leftovers ever!

I have doubled this before but quite frankly it is best when made in smaller batches like this. If you need more just throw in another since it’s super quick to make.

What type of rice do you use to make chocolate rice pudding?

You are to use white rice that starts off uncooked for this. Do not use instant or Minute rice as it will not turn out right at all and just be mush at the end when pressure cooked. Even if made on the stove I think long grain or sushi rice is best so it soaks up the cocoa and vanilla flavors.

Instant Pot Chocolate Rice Pudding Ingredients

Pay close attention once you lift the lid and make sure you are stirring constantly so it doesn’t burn. You’ll want to temper the egg with some of the hot mixture too.

1. Uncooked long grain white rice
   1. I have not experimented with brown rice and I don’t think it would turn out very good anyway
   2. short grain rice should be fine, haven’t tested with arborio rice either
2. Butter or plant based alternative for a dairy free option
3. Sugar
4. Vanilla
5. Cocoa powder, there is milk and dark versions to choose from
6. Milk
7. Evaporated milk
8. Egg

We’ve made this slow cooker rice pudding recipe too you should try! Of course that takes quite a bit longer but is a great option if you want to just set it and forget it during the holidays. Try them all so you can see which you prefer and make it more often for dessert at your home.

Dairy Free Chocolate Rice Pudding

If you needed a dairy free alternative it is quite easy to do. I have made similar adjustments for Instant Pot tapioca pudding too. You can use a plant based butter alternative that tastes almost the same. You can find a DF evaporated milk option online too. Here’s how we made it. There is a printable recipe card at the bottom of the post too:

1. Put your Instant Pot or pressure cooker on saute and add your butter until it melts.  Add your uncooked rice and stir. 
2. Pour in your milk and water and stir. Add vanilla, 1/2 cup sugar, and your unsweetened cocoa and stir well until well combined and it resembles chocolate milk color without any cocoa clumps. 
   Put lid on IP and close pressure valve.
3. Set to manual, pressure cook, high pressure for 14 minutes cook time.  When it beeps do a quick release and lift lid carefully. 
4. In a small bowl combine egg and evaporated milk and whisk together.  Add 1/2 c. of hot rice pudding mixture from pot in with your egg/milk mixture, stir. This will temper your egg.
5. Add another 1/2 c., stir, then add that mixture into your IP. Set Instant Pot to saute and when it begins to bubble stir slowly for about 2 minutes or until it thickens a bit.

Immediately pour your finished pudding into cool dishes. This is important so it doesn’t continue cooking and get mushy. Then fill pot with soapy water so it’s easier to clean later. 😉 Looking for more pressure cooker desserts? It’s fun to make chocolate Instant Pot cake for dessert too.

Instant Pot potato corn chowder is an amazing dinner idea if you want to use this machine to make your main dish and treat later.