The best twice baked potatoes are here! Tender stuffed potatoes with bacon, cheese and sour cream are the perfect appetizer made in your oven or air fryer.
If you’ve ever had the best twice baked potatoes at a restaurant, I bet you wish you could make them yourself. Now you can!! Have an air fryer? They’ll come out really crispy that way. If not, we have oven directions for you too so everyone can enjoy this favorite football appetizer.
- Let’s start with good old fashioned stuffed potatoes in the oven shall we?
First: What are the best potatoes for baking?
Russet potatoes are the best for baking. They are a high starch potato that when baked, lend a light and mealy texture. The skins are a bit thicker than the Gold version which is necessary when making stuffed potatoes.
- After all, this baked potato recipe requires crispy skins!
Should potatoes be washed before cooking?
Yes!! Wait to wash the potatoes until the last moment before using them though. This should include some scrubbing to get any dirt and debris off. Some may be lodged in the eyes of the potatoes. Since most Idaho potatoes are grown in a sandy or volcanic soil, the scrubbing can be pretty minimal but necessary nonetheless.
- Once you’ve done this and dried them well, poke each one with a fork all over.
- Preheat oven, then rub olive oil all over them liberally.
- Put each one on a lined baking sheet sheet, covering with aluminum foil first makes clean up a lot easier.
- Make potatoes in the oven as usual.
- heat oven to 400 degrees for 50 minutes
- Allow to cool enough for you to handle them.
- Slice potato in half lengthwise, scoop out insides leaving 1/2″ thick potato flesh
- Mix inners and toppings in a bowl like mashed potatoes and refill skins with potato mixture
- Bake again at 350 degrees for 15 – 20 minutes or until top cheese is melted
- Enjoy your side dish or party food!
Should you wrap a baked potato in foil?
This was kinda’ the old fashioned method my parents did. Do not do this for baking. Foil holds in moisture and steams the potatoes, resulting in a “boiled” taste and texture. Instead, turn the potatoes over halfway through the baking time to prevent browning of the undersides where they touch the baking tray or oven rack.
- For stuffed potatoes you also want crispy skins, using foil will make them soft instead.
Can you make baked potatoes the night before?
If you’re making this for a holiday or crowd you could do this. For best results cook them, scoop out the middles and refrigerate the empty skins and mash separately. Then take skins and inners out and allow them to get to room temperature first. Add cheese, bacon, sour cream and everything else and mash as usual.
- Fill potatoes at this time and pop them into the oven for the last part of the directions at 350 for about 15 minutes.
Now: How do you cook potatoes in an air fryer?
- SO to make these double stuffed potatoes this way you’d first make air fryer baked potatoes. You can even make sweet potato in the air fryer.
- it’s similar directions but the skins will come out WAY crispier
- I recommend adding sea salt on the skins for over the top air fryer twice potatoes
Then allow them to cool, slice, scoop out middles, add goodies, sprinkle remaining cheese on top and follow the same directions from step 7 down.
What can you fill the best twice baked potatoes with?
The possibilities are really endless but to name a few:
- Sour cream and butter
- Garlic salt
- Salt and pepper
- Cream cheese
- Bacon bits
- Green onions
- Diced onion
- Lots of cheese inside and on top
- Top with crispy fried onions too!
How do you heat up twice baked potatoes if you have leftovers?
- Remove stuffed potato skins from the refrigerator
- Brush the skins and top with butter
- Cover potato with a damp paper towel to keep in the moisture
- Put on a microwave safe dish
- Microwave for 2 to 3 minutes until warm
Other potato recipe ideas you’ll love.
- These air fryer Hasselback potatoes
- Loaded baked potato soup in the crockpot is great.
- Instant Pot potato salad is another tailgate recipe favorite.
- Air fryer mashed potatoes
- This is the best potato corn chowder you’ll ever try.
- Try a potato medley too.
Best Twice Baked Potatoes
- Put foil on a baking sheet and preheat oven to 400 degrees F.
- Wash and dry potatoes, poke several holes all around each one with a fork.
- Generously coat potatoes with olive oil, sprinkle with salt, and place on baking sheet.
- Bake for 50-60 minutes or until tender in the very center of each one.
- Allow them to cool enough so you can handle them. Then cut each one in half lengthwise.
- Scoop out the center leaving 1/2" thick walls and the skins in tact. Put halves on baking sheet.
- Turn down oven to 350 degrees.
- IN a mixing bowl add the scooped out potato insides, softened butter, salt, pepper, 1/2 c. sour cream or softened cream cheese. Mix until well combined.
- Add half the cheese and bacon and mix gently in. Now fill the skins with this mixture until there is no more left. Top with remaining cheese and bacon.
- Bake for approx. 15-18 minutes or until cheese has melted.
- Can put some sour cream in a pastry bag or freezer bag. Cut off tip and squeeze on top in the shape of football lacing for fun. Top with chives.