Name: Homemade Pumpkin Butter
Prep time: 10 min
Cook time: 9 min
Total time: 19 min
Ingredients: 1 small/med. pumpkin (or about 12 oz pumpkin puree); 1/4-1/3 c water (or apple cider, amt. depends on how thick you want it); 5 tbsp brown sugar (heaping); 3/4 tsp Pumpkin Pie Spice; 1/8-1/4 tsp nutmeg (depending on how much you like that flavor); 1/4 tsp cinnamon; 1 tbsp sugar (or more depending on how sweet you want it)

Jump to Recipe

How to cook fresh pumpkin fast and then turn it into the most delicious Instant Pot homemade pumpkin butter in just 20 minutes! Perfect spread for toast and more!

I was given some pumpkins out of a relatives garden the other day and since I hate letting things go to waste I started to think of something I had never made before and I came up with homemade pumpkin butter! It was so much easier to make than I had thought and had wonderful Fall flavors that I am obsessed with. Using our easy pressure cooker pumpkin recipe (link below), a blender and spoon we now have a few jars we can now spread on toast and were so great on pancakes too. Definitely one of our favorite Fall Instant Pot recipes we’ve made recently.

This is what the pumpkin looked like we used for this.

Did you know there are tons of different varieties of pumpkins?

This one is a long pumpkin pie variety that is oblong rather than the traditional shape you’re used to seeing….taste the same though really.

Have you ever made fresh pumpkin puree before? I honestly hadn’t until the other day when I figured I would give it a whirl in my Instant Pot and it was amazingly easy to do and came out ever so tender.

So easy to scoop the insides out, and throw it in my blender to start making homemade pumpkin butter which is way better than store bought because you can adjust how much of cinnamon or nutmeg goes inside.

I prefer a bit of nutmeg but sometimes it is overpowering so I like being in control and making it perfect for us.

It’s great to be able to adjust how sweet it is too……

I had never made Instant Pot pumpkin butter before so it was a bit of an experimentation process until I got it just right.

I think it came out really tasty and the perfect way to bring in those Fall flavors we all love, I am obsessed with everything pumpkin I tell you!!

Here’s how I made it……..

The closest thing I have found to match this spread would be the Trader Joe’s pumpkin butter I have bought in the past…..but it’s so easy to make it’s worth it to do it yourself. 😉

Here’s what you need to make this easy homemade pumpkin butter

Our easy pressure cooker pumpkin instructions – or use a can of pumpkin puree
Blender
Water or apple cider
Brown sugar
Pumpkin pie spice
Nutmeg
Cinnamon
Sugar

There are tons of pumpkin butter uses but we love it on toast!

Here’s a printable version of our Fall recipe:

Print Pin